Nashville SC picked up all three points against a flying Columbus Crew side. This marks the 10th unbeaten home game for the Boys in Gold as they continue their Supporters Shield chase.

• Players begin with a base grade of 6 and can increase or decrease their rating based on performance.
• Players must play a minimum of 15 minutes to earn a rating.
Joe Willis - 8.5
Huge response from the goalkeeper after a disappointing mistake in Fort Lauderdale. He came up with a couple of good saves and commanded his box really well in the second half.
Stock: Up
JOE. SAID. NO.
— Nashville SC (@NashvilleSC) July 17, 2025
👏 pic.twitter.com/pYFccBrj1k
Dan Lovitz - 7.0
It was a demanding game, but Dan Lovitz kept up with the pace of it.
Stock: Unchanged
Jack Maher - 8.5
Both centerbacks had big games, but for Jack Maher specifically, this was a huge step into solidifying his spot in the starting XI. He had a couple of incredible last ditch efforts and was overall very secure off the ball and with it.
Stock: Up
Walker Zimmerman - 8.5
This was the first start since March 1 for the United States international. He reminded everyone why he was three time MLS defender of the year and this club's captain.
Stock: Up
Andy Nájar - 9.5
Man of the match, pretty much everything good this team does in attack starts with Andy Nájar. Running out of superlatives at this point, best right back in the league.
Stock: Up - Not sure if it can go any higher
What a beauty. ✨@NashvilleSC's three MLS all-stars link up to extend the lead. pic.twitter.com/u3MtGoLx61
— Major League Soccer (@MLS) July 17, 2025
Patrick Yazbek - 7.5
Maybe we got used to it, but Patrick Yazbek has been one of the most consistent players for this Nashville side, and this game was no different. If he can add a bit of attacking edge to his game, he will be one of the best midfielders in the league.
Stock: Unchanged
Eddi Tagseth - 7.5
71% of the earth is covered by water. Eddi Tagseth covers the rest.
Stock: Unchanged
Alex Muyl - 8.0
Alex Muyl battled the Crew throughout the match and dropped deeper when needed. He was also helpful going forward with his ball causing the own goal in the second minute. Pressing, counter-pressing, defending and running up and down the pitch, great performance.
Stock: Unchanged
Don't let the fact that this ended up as an own goal take away from what a fantastic passing move this was from Nashville. Seven passes from goalkeeper to goal in about 12 seconds. pic.twitter.com/B1UoKVF7fm
— Ben Wright (@benwright) July 17, 2025
Johnny Pérez - 5.5
The winger seemed a step behind everyone else in attack. A below average game by the standards he set with his good performances. He also picked up a yellow, meaning he'll be suspended for the weekend's game due to yellow card accumulation.
Stock: Unchanged
Hany Mukhtar - 9.0
Hany Mukhtar is fully in MVP mode, a relentless shift from the German.
Stock: Up
Sam Surridge - 8.5
The Englishman's confidence continues to show as he leads the Golden Boot race again. His positioning on the goal was nice, but his assist on the second goal was even better.
Stock: Unchanged
Substitutes
Ahmed Qasem - 7.5
Huge confidence boost for Ahmed Qasem coming in and leaving his mark on the match with an assist. He also took care of his defensive duties, something BJ Callaghan will be happy about.
Stock: Unchanged
Teal Bunbury - N/A
The veteran did well to close the game out and kill some time off the clock.
Stock: Unchanged
Bryan Acosta - N/A
Minutes have been far and in between, but Bryan Acosta has looked solid so far.
Stock: Unchanged
Gastón Brugman - N/A
Did what he needed to close out the game.
Stock: Unchanged
Josh Bauer - N/A
See above.
Stock: Unchanged
Manager
BJ Callaghan - 9.0
BJ Callaghan's tactics have been deservedly praised multiple times, but credit should be given to his man-management as well. Nashville's ability to play their style and adapt to game state when needed starts with their head coach. If he wasn't in the Coach of the Year discussion, beating Wilfred Nancy 3-0 should get him there.
Stock: Up
FT: Nashville make a statement against Columbus. pic.twitter.com/CxGmEDJ5z6
— SixOneFive Soccer (@615Soccer) July 17, 2025