Skip to content

Ben Wright's MLS Cup Playoffs bracket

Picking the winners for every round of the MLS Cup Playoffs

The 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs kick off tonight, with four teams (Orlando vs Cincinnati and Seattle vs Salt Lake) fighting to get through the Wild Card round and into the playoffs proper.

My 2026 MLS Cup playoffs bracket
Quick, round-by-round thoughts on what's going to unfold next month across the entire postseason

I'm stealing a page from TacticsFreeZone's Matt Doyle and making my picks for each round of the playoffs, with some general thoughts on each matchup sprinkled in along the way.

While you're at it, subscribe to TacticsFreeZone for some of the best analysis of MLS out there!

CTA Image

Tactics Free Zone is the premier place for high-level soccer analysis, with a focus on MLS and the USMNT.

Learn more

Make your own picks here

Wild Card Round

(8) Orlando City vs (9) FC Cincinnati

In a meta sense, I don't really care who wins this matchup. You can't be a serious threat for the MLS Cup with one of the worst defenses MLS has ever seen, an honor both of these teams share. I think Cincinnati are a slightly less-bad team at the moment, so I'm going with them. Whoever wins is going home in the next round.

WINNER: FC Cincinnati

(8) Seattle Sounders vs (9) Real Salt Lake

Losing Jackson Ragen really, really hurts Seattle. I think he's their second-most important player behind Cristian Roldan, and that's a tough, tough ask for a team who have built a lot of their identity around being a pretty solid team. But they're playing at home, and for some reason I just trust Seattle more in matches that count.

WINNER: Seattle Sounders (but I don't feel great about it)

Round One (Best of Three)

(1) Nashville SC vs (9) FC Cincinnati

I don't think the opponent matters here. Nashville are a wagon; they don't lose games at home, and they score buckets of goals. Maybe Orlando or Cincinnati can sneak a single result past them (I would be shocked if that happens), but a best-of-three format makes this feel almost insurmountable. Especially going up against teams that leak goals left and right, Nashville feel like a lock.

WINNER: Nashville SC

(1) Vancouver Whitecaps vs (8) Seattle Sounders

I actually think that Seattle are uniquely capable of eliminating Vancouver on their day. Despite Seattle's struggles this year, their first-choice XI is full of match-winners when healthy. The "when healthy" bit has been the key, and they'll be without Ragen for the first match here as well (he was suspended two games for a hit on Jacob Shaffelburg). I think this will be tight, but picking Vancouver here.

WINNER: Vancouver Whitecaps (in three)

(2) Inter Miami vs (7) Columbus Crew

Inter Miami are finally answering the age-old question, "what if you took the best player of all time and threw him into a bad MLS team?" Because without Lionel Messi, Inter Miami aren't even a playoff team. They've allowed 59 goals, the 12th-most in the league, and have struggled against actually good teams.

Columbus Crew head into the playoffs in the best nine-match form we've ever seen to close out a season, and under Laurent Courtois, they methodically pull teams apart. I think Messi can still hit a level that no one else in MLS can, but this team is much, much worse than the one that lifted MLS Cup last year. I'm going with the upset here.

WINNER: Columbus Crew (in three)

(2) FC Dallas vs (7) Portland Timbers

I'll be honest; I've re-written my prediction here three or four times, because I can see either team winning. FC Dallas play the boring, pragmatic soccer that tends to win playoff games, and Portland head into this series in fantastic form. Christophe Velde is quietly one of the better attackers in MLS at the moment, and I think they match up really well with Dallas.

So give me Dallas in three.

WINNER: FC Dallas (in three)

(3) New England Revolution vs (6) Philadelphia Union

I really like what New England have done this year. Marko Mitrović is already one of the top young coaches in MLS, Carles Gil is still an elite playmaker, Matt Turner is maybe the best goalkeeper in MLS, and Jack Harrison is back and healthy. But, man, Philadelphia just have the it factor to them. Their press is brutal, they have match winners like Cavan Sullivan, Milan Iloski, and Bruno Damiani. This is one of the series I'm most excited about.

WINNER: Philadelphia Union (in three)

(3) St. Louis City vs (6) Los Angeles FC

This one is pretty simple: I think St. Louis are a very good team, and LAFC are not. Even with elite players like Heung-min Son and Dénis Bouanga, I don't think LAFC are built to be a real contender, and I certainly don't think they match up well with St. Louis. St. Louis are getting healthy and have proven to be able to win when it counts. I think they'll advance pretty comfortably.

WINNER: St. Louis City

(4) Chicago Fire vs (5) Charlotte FC

Neither of these teams particularly move me, but I think the Fire have significantly more top-end talent, and will overcome Charlotte's 𝗉̶𝗋̶𝖺̶𝗀̶𝗆̶𝖺̶𝗍̶𝗂̶𝖼̶ reactive game model. I'm picking the Fire, but this is the Round One series I'm least excited to watch.

WINNER: Chicago Fire

(4) San Jose Earthquakes vs (5) Houston Dynamo

Aside from Guilherme, the Houston Dynamo haven't been able to consistently generate chances. Meanwhile, San Jose Earthquakes had the best 12-game start to a season in MLS history when they were healthy, and their dip in form was the result of some brutal injuries to their best players. If Niko Tsakiris and Timo Werner can stay healthy, I think they'll cause real problems in the West. They'll certainly be able to handle Houston.

WINNER: San Jose Earthquakes

Conference Semifinals

Nashville SC vs Chicago Fire

Do the Fire have enough to take down Nashville in a single-elimination game? Absolutely. Do I think they'll do it at Geodis Park, where Nashville haven't just not lost, but have steamrolled teams all year? No, I don't.

WINNER: Nashville SC

Vancouver Whitecaps vs San Jose Earthquakes

This would be one of the best matchups in the playoffs, and I think a healthy 'Quakes can push Vancouver to the limits here, who never quite figured out how to be as dangerous without Sebastian Berhalter. I'm going with the 'Caps and home-field advantage, but it's going to be a banger.

WINNER: Vancouver Whitecaps

St. Louis City vs FC Dallas

St. Louis are significantly better with the ball than Dallas, control the tempo and terms of games at Energizer Park, and can also press you to death. I'm going with them.

WINNER: St. Louis City

Philadelphia Union vs Columbus Crew

Another game I absolutely can't wait to watch between two completely opposite styles of play. I think the Crew can really push Philadelphia here, but the Union are relentless, and I trust in their match-winners more than Columbus's at this point.

WINNER: Philadelphia Union

Conference Finals

Nashville SC vs Philadelphia Union

Under BJ Callaghan, Nashville have been pretty good against the Union, winning both games in 2025 and drawing both 0-0 in 2026, including a home leg in which Nashville rotated heavily.

Nashville can be troubled by a high press, as seen against Red Bull New York in their final home match of the season. It's also really hard for teams to press them for 90 minutes at Geodis Park, and Nashville eventually take control. This will be close, but I'm picking Nashville.

WINNER: Nashville SC

Vancouver Whitecaps vs St. Louis City

St. Louis's 3-1 win at Vancouver in September is one of the best individual performances I've seen all year. Neither team are entering the playoffs in fantastic form, but St. Louis's ability to both control games with the ball or with a high press is really tough to counter.

Vancouver, on the other hand, are one of the best teams in MLS with the ball, and they'll be playing at home, where they've won 11 matches in 2026. The contrast of styles here is going to be fantastic to watch. I think it could go either way, but I really rate this St. Louis team.

WINNER: St. Louis City (in extra time)

MLS Cup Final

Nashville SC vs St. Louis City

Nashville have won big games and are elite at home. St. Louis were clobbered by Columbus on the road in the US Open Cup final and held on for a gutsy, ugly win. These are two really, really good teams, and share a lot of similarities in both their trajectories and how they play.

Nashville at home is a different animal. We've seen all year that they've found ways to win, even in matches where they haven't played especially well. In the biggest game they've ever played, I'm not betting against them.

WINNER: Nashville SC


You can make your own bracket here. Make sure to tag SixOneFive Soccer on socials when you share it!

CTA Image

Tired of cheering for bad Nashville sports teams? We've got you covered.

Nashville SC are the best team in Major League Soccer, and we're offering 50% off new yearly subscriptions. Take it from us; following a Nashville team can actually be fun!

Subscribe for a full year for just $15!

Comments

Latest