Skip to content

Why Nashville SC won't win MLS Cup

A hater's guide to what could go wrong for the Boys In Gold

Christina Moore-SixOneFive Soccer

On Sunday, Nashville SC will kick off their playoff campaign.

The Boys In Gold haven't just been good this season; they've been historically good, winning the Supporters' Shield (the trophy for the best regular-season record), smashing the league record for most points in a season, and going unbeaten at home, winning 15 of their 17 regular-season games at Geodis Park.

Nashville SC: "We want to be the standard of MLS"
Nashville celebrate their historic 2026 season on an unforgettable night, while hungry for even more in the playoffs

With home-field advantage secured through the playoffs, including a potential MLS Cup final on December 18, Nashville go into the postseason as favorites. Per Polymarket, the league's official betting partner, they have a 24% chance at winning it all. SixOneFive Soccer's in-house simulation model, the 'Yotes have a 25% chance to win it all, second-only to Vancouver's 27%.

Today, though, we're embracing negativity. We're looking at the reasons why Nashville won't win MLS Cup for the first time in club history, and why the current season will end in disappointment.

Don't worry; we'll get into the positives tomorrow, of which there are many. For today, at least, we're haters.

CTA Image

Tired of cheering for bad Nashville sports teams? We've got you covered.

Nashville SC are the best team in Major League Soccer, and we're offering 50% off new yearly subscriptions. Take it from us; following a Nashville team can actually be fun!

Subscribe for a full year for just $15!

Supporters' Shield winners don't win MLS Cup

Christina Moore-SixOneFive Soccer

Despite the Shield securing home-field advantage in the playoffs, Shield winners don't take home MLS Cup... usually. Since 2015 (and excluding the 2020 Covid-shortened season), only two of 10 Shield winners have lifted MLS Cup at the end of the season, leading to whispers of a curse among more superstitious fans, and math that doesn't look great for the data nerds.

Is the Supporters' Shield cursed?
The numbers behind why Shield winners struggle to lift MLS Cup

The single-season points record has been broken three times in the last five years. After a 73-point campaign in 2021, the New England Revolution fell in the Eastern Conference semifinals after a first-round bye, exiting unceremoniously. Similarly, Inter Miami crashed out in 2024 after hitting 74 points, falling in a best-of-three series to Atlanta United in one of the biggest upsets in league history.

This isn't a guarantee that Nashville's season will end in disaster by any means, but rather evidence of a cold, hard fact: playoffs are a crap shoot. Even the most elite team in MLS can lose in a single-elimination match. There's also an uptick in intensity and fight during playoffs that is impossible to quantify, and tests the mentality of a team in a way that the data can't accurately engage with.

Nashville are going into the 2026 playoffs with history against them.

This post is for paying subscribers only

Subscribe

Already have an account? Sign In

Latest